Complete Comparison
Compare All 15 Verified Olive Oils
Side-by-side comparison of all 15 verified extra virgin olive oils with scores, polyphenol levels, origins, supply chain pathways, and transparency ratings.
6
High-Polyphenol Oils
8
Estate Productions
4
Cooperative Models
81-92
Score Range
Filter & Sort
Showing 15 of 15 oils
Olive Oil | Score | Polyphenols | Origin | Harvest | Production | Pathway | Special Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MANNI OilEditor's Pick | 92 /100 | High | Italy (Tuscany) | Full | Estate | 6-8 weeks | Editor's PickThird-party verified |
| EVO3 Olive Oil | 88 /100 | High | Greece (Lesvos) | Full | Estate | 6-8 weeks | Organic certified3-variety blend |
| Schirinzi | 88 /100 | Medium | Italy (Puglia) | Full | Estate | 5-6 weeks | 60-year family estateBag-in-box option |
| ENZO Olive Oil | 87 /100 | High | Italy | Full | Estate | 5-7 weeks | Early harvest |
| Canaan Palestine | 87 /100 | High | Palestine | Full | Estate | 5-7 weeks | Fair trade certified |
| Gundry MD Polyphenol-Rich | 86 /100 | High | Morocco | Partial | Direct-to-Consumer | 5-6 weeks | 30x polyphenol claimDTC model |
| Mer des Oliviers | 85 /100 | High | Greece (Delphi) | Full | Cooperative | 6-8 weeks | Specialty curated |
| Yaya's EVOO | 85 /100 | Medium | Greece (Sparta) | Partial | Estate | 6-8 weeks | Family estate |
| ZOE Wild Olive Oil | 84 /100 | High | Greece (wild) | Partial | Cooperative | 6-8 weeks | Wild harvest |
| Saratoga Olive Oil Co | 84 /100 | Medium | California | Full | Estate | 3-4 weeks | COOC certifiedDomestic |
| Olive Oil Lovers | 84 /100 | Medium | Multiple (curated) | Full | Cooperative | 6-8 weeks | Multi-source curated |
| Nonna Live | 83 /100 | Medium | Italy | Partial | Estate | 6-8 weeks | Heritage recipe |
| Secolari Artisan Oils | 83 /100 | Medium | California | Full | Estate | 3-4 weeks | COOC certifiedSmall-batch |
| Bonitates EVOO | 82 /100 | High | Turkey | Partial | Estate | 6-8 weeks | 500 Reasons brand |
| Deliba | 81 /100 | Medium | Italy (Sinopolese) | Partial | Estate | 6-8 weeks | Monocultivar |
Supply Chain Pathway Comparison
Estate Production
8 oils use estate-bottled production for maximum quality control.
Single-source from grove to bottle. Fastest pathways (3-8 weeks).
Cooperative Model
4 oils use cooperative or curated selection models.
Quality verification across multiple producers. 6-8 week pathways.
Direct-to-Consumer
1 oil uses direct-to-consumer for maximum freshness control.
No retail middlemen. 5-6 week pathway with lab verification.
Key Findings
Highest Scores (90+)
- MANNI Oil (92) - Estate-bottled Tuscan with third-party verification
Fastest Pathways (3-4 weeks)
- Saratoga & Secolari - California domestic production
High-Polyphenol Leaders
- 6 oils verified as high-polyphenol (300+ mg/kg)
Full Harvest Transparency
- 8 oils provide complete harvest date disclosure